How to Set Social Media Benchmarks Without Industry Averages

Set social media benchmarks from your own last 30 to 90 days of posts. Use the median, not the average, to judge each post and set realistic targets.

How to Set Social Media Benchmarks Without Industry Averages

To set social media benchmarks, collect the results from your last 30 to 90 days of posts, find the median for each metric on each network, and treat that as your normal. Judge every new post against that number, not against an industry average that was built from accounts nothing like yours.

The median works better than the average because one unusually good or bad post can drag an average far from what a typical post does. This guide walks through the whole process, with a spreadsheet layout you can copy.

Key takeaways

  • Your own recent posts are a more useful benchmark than industry averages, because they reflect your audience, your content and your network.
  • Use 30 to 90 days of posts and work out the median, not the average, so one outlier doesn't distort your baseline.
  • Benchmark each network separately, and compare like with like (video with video, carousel with carousel).
  • Set a "weak", "normal" and "strong" range for each metric, then set a small, realistic target to move the median up.
  • Review the baseline every quarter, because your normal will change as your account does.

Why are industry averages a poor benchmark for a small account?

Industry averages blend together accounts of very different sizes, ages, budgets and content styles, so they rarely describe what is realistic for you. A local bakery with a few hundred followers and a software company with a full-time social team may be counted in the same figure.

There are other problems too:

  • You can't see how the number was built. Which metric, which post types, which period, which follower range?
  • Definitions differ. Engagement rate can be calculated against followers, reach or views, and the results are not comparable. See our engagement rate formula guide for the common versions.
  • They tell you nothing about change. What matters for a small business is whether this month is better than last month, not whether you beat a number from somewhere else.

Industry figures can be a loose sense check when you are brand new and have no history. Once you have a few weeks of posts, your own data is the better yardstick.

What is a social media baseline?

A baseline is the typical result your posts get right now, measured per network and per metric. It answers the question: "If I post something ordinary, what should I expect?"

A good baseline has three parts:

  1. A typical value (the median).
  2. A normal range around it, so you know what counts as weak and what counts as strong.
  3. A time window (the last 30 to 90 days) so it reflects how your account performs today, not two years ago.

Once you have those, every new post gets a simple verdict: below normal, normal or above normal. That is far more useful than "how did this do?" with nothing to compare it to.

How do you build a baseline from your last 30 to 90 days?

Export or copy your post results for the last 30 to 90 days into one sheet, then calculate the median for each metric on each network. Use 90 days if you post less than three or four times a week, so you have enough posts to be meaningful. Use 30 days if you post daily.

Step 1: Pick your window and your posts

Choose the most recent 30 to 90 days. Try to have at least 10 posts per network. If you have fewer, widen the window rather than trusting a tiny sample.

Leave out anything that distorts normal performance, such as a paid boost or a giveaway. Note those separately and keep them out of the baseline.

Step 2: Choose one or two metrics per network

Don't track everything. Pick the metrics that match what that network is for. Our guide to social media KPIs can help you decide, and if reach, impressions and views are muddled in your head, this explainer will help.

Step 3: Record one row per post

For each post, note the date, network, format, topic and your chosen metrics. In PilotPost Insights you can see views, likes, comments and shares for Facebook, Instagram, Threads, TikTok, YouTube and Bluesky in one place, which saves copying figures from several apps. For other networks, use each network's own analytics.

Step 4: Calculate the median

Sort the results for one metric from lowest to highest and take the middle value. If you have an even number of posts, take the two middle values and find the point halfway between them. Spreadsheets do this with a MEDIAN formula.

Step 5: Mark your weak and strong lines

From the same sorted list, note roughly where the bottom quarter ends and the top quarter begins. Anything below the first line is weak for you. Anything above the second is strong. Everything between is normal.

Why use the median instead of the average?

The median is the middle result, so a single post that goes unusually well or badly cannot pull it far off course. The average adds everything up, so one outlier can make your "typical" number look much better than reality.

Here is an illustrative example. Twelve posts got these views, sorted from lowest to highest:

120, 135, 140, 150, 160, 170, 180, 200, 210, 240, 300, 2,400

  • The average is about 367 views, a figure that only one post has beaten comfortably.
  • The median is 175 views (halfway between 170 and 180), which reflects what a normal post actually does.

If you used 367 as your target, almost every post would look like a failure. If you used 175, you can see that most posts are fine and the 2,400 post is worth studying.

That outlier is useful too, just not for the baseline. Flag it, work out why it did well, and see whether you can repeat it.

Which metrics should you benchmark on each network?

Benchmark the metric that best reflects the job each network does for you, plus one supporting metric. The table below is a sensible starting point, not a rule.

NetworkPrimary metricSupporting metricNote
InstagramReach or views per postSaves and sharesBenchmark Reels, carousels and single images separately
Facebook PageReach or views per postComments and sharesSplit link posts from native images and video
TikTokViews per videoShares and commentsUse views on the video, not follower count
YouTubeViews per video in the first 28 daysWatch timeShorts and long videos need separate baselines
LinkedInImpressions per postCommentsText posts, carousels and polls behave differently
ThreadsViews per postRepliesShort text and image posts can be mixed if you post both
BlueskyLikes and repostsRepliesSmall audiences make the median especially valuable
XImpressions per postReplies and repostsWith a limit of one scheduled post a day, 90 days gives a solid sample
PinterestOutbound clicks or saves per PinImpressionsPins build over time, so use a longer window

If you want a rate rather than a raw count, divide engagement by reach or views, and use the same method every time. Our Instagram engagement rate calculator can do this for Instagram.

How do you split benchmarks by format and topic?

Give each format its own median, because a carousel and a short video rarely perform the same way. Mixing them gives you a baseline that describes neither.

A simple way to keep this tidy:

  • Format: video, carousel, single image, text-only, link post.
  • Topic: pick three to five content pillars, such as "how-to", "behind the scenes", "customer proof", "offer".
  • Labels: apply a label to each post when you schedule it. In PilotPost you can use labels for format and topic, so when you review results later you can sort by them instead of guessing.

Only split as far as your data allows. If a format has fewer than five posts in your window, group it with something similar or wait until you have more.

Spreadsheet template: your benchmark sheet

Copy this layout into a spreadsheet. One tab per network keeps it simple.

ColumnWhat to enter
DatePublish date
FormatVideo, carousel, image, text, link
TopicYour content pillar
Primary metricViews, reach or impressions
Supporting metricSaves, comments, shares or replies
Boosted?Yes or no (exclude "yes" from the baseline)
VerdictBelow, normal or above

At the bottom of each tab, add this summary block:

SummaryFormula ideaExample result
MedianMEDIAN of the primary metric column175
Weak lineValue roughly a quarter of the way up the sorted list150
Strong lineValue roughly three quarters of the way up210
Number of postsCOUNT of rows12
WindowFirst and last date90 days

If you prefer a ready-made structure for reporting results, our social media report template is a good companion.

How do you set realistic targets from your baseline?

Set a target that moves your median up by a small, achievable step over the next 30 to 90 days, rather than aiming at a figure borrowed from someone else. A modest rise that you hit builds confidence and shows what is working.

Try this approach:

  1. Start with your median. For example, 175 views per post.
  2. Choose a modest improvement, such as a 10 per cent lift in the median over the next quarter. That is about 192 views in this example.
  3. Pick one change to test, not five. For example, a stronger opening line, a different format or a more consistent posting slot.
  4. Re-run the median at the end of the period and compare.

What counts as modest depends on your account, so treat 10 per cent as a starting point and adjust it. If your median barely moves in three months, you may need a bigger change in what you post, not more effort on the same thing. Our social media audit guide can help you find where to look.

When testing posting times, compare the medians for each time slot instead of single posts. Our guide to the best time to post on social media explains how to treat general advice as a starting point only.

How do you use the benchmark to judge a new post?

Wait until the post has had enough time to collect most of its results, then compare it with your weak, normal and strong lines. Give short-lived posts a day or two and longer-lived formats, such as video and Pins, longer.

Use a simple verdict:

  • Below the weak line: note anything unusual (timing, topic, format, a thin opening line) but don't overreact to one post.
  • Between the lines: this is normal. Nothing to learn, nothing to fix.
  • Above the strong line: write down what was different and try to repeat it within the next few posts.

Look for patterns across several posts before you change your strategy. One result is a data point. Three similar results are a pattern.

When should you update your benchmarks?

Update your benchmarks every quarter, or sooner after a big change such as a new posting rhythm, a new format or a large jump in followers. Your normal moves as your account grows, so an old baseline will make you feel better or worse than you should.

A quick quarterly routine:

  • Roll the window forward so it covers the latest 30 to 90 days.
  • Recalculate the median and the weak and strong lines.
  • Compare with the last quarter and write one sentence on what changed.
  • Set the next target.

If you manage several accounts, repeat this per client and keep the sheets in the same shape, which also makes monthly reporting easier. Our guide to social media reporting for clients shows how to explain these numbers simply.

If you want to spend less time collecting results and more time acting on them, you can start a free trial of PilotPost, schedule across your networks and check Insights in one place.

FAQ

How many posts do I need to set a reliable benchmark?

Aim for at least 10 posts per network and format, over a window of 30 to 90 days. If you have fewer, use a longer window or group similar formats. A rough baseline from a small sample is still better than none, but treat it with caution.

Should I include boosted or paid posts in my baseline?

No. Paid promotion changes who sees a post, so it will not reflect your normal organic performance. Keep paid posts in a separate list and benchmark them on their own.

What if my account is brand new and I have no history?

Post consistently for four to six weeks first, then build your first baseline from what you have. In the meantime, a published industry range can give you a loose sense of scale, but don't treat it as a target. Your own first median becomes the number to beat.

Is the median ever worse than the average?

The median is less useful when you have very few posts, because one or two results can still shift it. It can also hide a real shift if your top posts are getting much better while the rest stay flat. That is why it helps to check the strong line alongside the median.

How to Set Social Media Benchmarks Without Industry Averages